From the Hood : Policy Captcha

Do Politicians Dream of Electric Sheep?
By Lyndon Hood

I’ve recently taken an interest in concerns about social media robots may try to influence New Zealand elections. [Spoilers: maybe, maybe not very well, this probably isn’t the way to find out.]

But in this campaign it’s not just online events that strain credibility. So I decided to test the political parties to see if they are real. This is an important matter, not merely for democratic purposes but also because if they were robots most of them would be in violation of all three of Asimov’s laws.

There is a traditional question for this purpose.

I did consider actually sending this question to them and letting them reply. But, as a recently-departed Prime Minister who just made an estimated thirteen million dollars in tax free capital gains on his Parnell mansion was fond of saying, perception is reality. So I just wrote down what I thought they would say.

I’m not actually trained to deliver the Voight-Kampff test so you’ll have to draw your own conclusions.

***

QUESTION:

You’re in a desert walking along in the sand when all of the sudden you look down, and you see a tortoise, it’s crawling toward you. You reach down, you flip the tortoise over on its back. The tortoise lies on its back, its belly baking in the hot sun, beating its legs trying to turn itself over, but it cant, not without your help. But you’re not helping. Why is that?

***

ANSWERS:

NATIONAL

What this turtle needs is some personal responsibility. A National-led Government will offer the turtle a drug programme and a dinky little ladder with instructions for turning itself back over. If the turtle fails to comply within two weeks we will wedge its shell in place and leave it there.

[I kept trying to tell them it wasn’t a turtle, it was a tortoise. They told me I was wrong.]

LABOUR

While the previous Labour Government may have put a tortoise on its back, National has spent nine years denying there even are tortoises in New Zealand. During that time the tortoise has gotten much, much thirstier. We welcome their recognition of the problem but only we can be trusted to take this issue seriously.

Also, the tortoise probably has a foreign-sounding name.

GREENS

A tortoise encountered in the wild in Aotearoa would probably have been released by a pet owner who was not adequately prepared for its extended lifespan and should be dealt with appropriately. But a system that requires someone to kill and eat tortoises to feed their children is unacceptable in an advanced country.

NZ FIRST

The tortoise definitely had a foreign-sounding name.

MĀORI

Well we could claim it was some whānau-based kaupapa Māori solution but I guess really it’d be because the tortoise looks like Mike Hosking.

I mean I can’t be the only one. [Doing tortoise impression] ‘Look at me, I’m Mike Hosking, I like to mislead the audience of a state broadcaster about how the election system works.’

So yeah you can stay on the back of your shell until you apologise properly, e hoa.

ACT

We believe the only really sustainable approach to preserving endangered species is farming them as pets or for food – as we like to call it, ‘charter national parks’.

In this case though, our hand turning the tortoise over is a metaphor for the invisible hand of the market so the tortoise will just have to deal with it.

UNITED FUTURE

This is an update to admit I entirely forgot about United Future.

TOP

I did not interrogate the TOP Party. This isn’t due to any threshold so please don’t sue.

I just thought someone who proposes radical technocratic solutions to issues and then goes on a rampage when challenged couldn’t possibly be robot.

********